On Saturday, Lili Reinhart shared an adorable Instagram selfie with the caption, "When I wanted eggs and toast at 1am."

When I wanted eggs and toast at 1am.

A post shared by Lili Reinhart (@lilireinhart) on

The photo shows the "Riverdale" actress bashfully pushing away the camera as she enjoys her classic diner breakfast.

But fans quickly realized Reinhart wasn't alone on her midnight diner run — she was with her co-star (and rumored boyfriend), Cole Sprouse.

Lili Reinhart's 1 am diner selfie with Cole Sprouse
photo: Instagram/@lilireinhart

Reinhart slyly tagged Sprouse in the upper right corner of the photo, letting fans know that Sprouse had accompanied her to the diner.

Her followers immediately swooned over the photos of #Sprousehart's late-night outing.

Did Cole Sprouse and Lili Reihart go out on a date at 1 am?
photo: Twitter
The way Lili Reinhart and Cole Sprouse look at each other
photo: Twitter

But some people read deeper into the 1 am "eggs and toast" date.

Instagram reactions to Cole and Lili's midnight date for eggs and toast
photo: Instagram

Judge-y fans decided they knew what Reinhart *really* meant.

Fan reactions to Lili Reinhart and Cole Sprouse's "midnight date"
photo: Instagram
Fan reactions to Cole Sprouse and Lili Reinhart's 1 a.m. egg run
photo: Twitter

Her followers pointed out that they aren't even dating...

Are Lili Reinhart and Cole Sprouse dating in real life?
photo: Twitter

But why *else* was she with Sprouse so late into the night?

Did Cole Sprouse and Lili Reinhart go on a date at 1 am?
photo: Instagram

Haters quickly accused Reinhart of exploiting her "relationship" with Sprouse for fame.

Is Lili Reinhart using Cole Sprouse for fame?
photo: Twitter

Others blasted Reinhart for hypocritically posting a photo of herself eating when she had just gone off on a fan for doing the same thing.

Lili Reinhart complained about fans taking her photo while she eats
photo: Twitter
Fan reactions to Lili Reinhart and Cole Sprouse's midnight eggs and toast run
photo: Instagram

In a now-deleted tweet, Reinhart called out two fans who tried to take her photo while she was eating. 

"To the two girls who are repeatedly photographing me as I'm eating my lunch... I see you," Reinhart allegedly wrote on Twitter. "You aren't slick…. that's fucking rude. ?????"

But there's a huuuuge difference between strangers taking unsolicited photos and a close friend (or in this case, a rumored boyfriend) jokingly snapping a cute candid. 

At the end of the day, Reinhart can control where the "eggs and toast" photo appears — but she can't control what nosy fans do with her image. 

However, most fans chalked up the diner photo as "Relationship Goals."

Cole Sprouse and Lili Reinhart made a 1 am diner run
photo: Twitter
Twitter reactions to Lili and Cole
photo: Twitter

So how about we let Sprousehart enjoy their eggs and toast shame-free, shall we?