Karity 21 Shadow In Matte, now $29
This palette has jewel, warm, cool, and neutral tones. The cool thing about this palette is you don't have to just settle for this all-matte version if you have too many mattes already. You can order this palette in these SAME colors with a different finish..
The Kat Von D Divine palette ($38, Sephora) has eight matte and shimmer shades. Neutrals are invited but it's the brights and greens that are the star of the show! This is the perfect alternative if you were *really* excited about the shimmery greens and blues in the fake Tarte's Icy Betch palette.
The Creepy Cute palette ($35, Strobe Cosmetics) has eight neon-pastel matte eye shadows.
The shades are: Tombstone (gray), Planchette (lavender), Creep It Real (minty green), Cold Shoulder (sky blue), Strawberry Milk (baby pink), Take A Hint (chartreuse blue), Void (black), and Third Eye (tangerine).