best black tights review

Portrait of the editor as a Tights Hater.

photo: Jess Torres / Revelist

I hate tights.

Maybe it's because I'm tall and have been scarred by a lifetime of tights that sag around my crotch. Maybe it's because I spent many years in un-air conditioned ballet studios, where no matter how hot it got, you could NEVER remove your regulation white tights.

Whatever the reason, I've always believed that tights are garbage. Uncomfortable, vagina-wedgie, disappointing garbage.

But more than that — I believed that there was no difference in tights, no matter how much money you spend on them. Cheap tights? Cheap trash. Designer tights? Expensive trash. Tights suck, no matter what... or so I thought.

Challenged by my tights-loving coworkers, I put two pairs of black tights — one cheap, one expensive — to the ultimate test.

And honestly, my life has forever been changed.

These are the black tights that I put to the test: Expensive versus cheap.

best black tights
photo: Alle / Revelist

Repping the luxury lifestyle, we have the Wolford 100 tights ($85, Shopbop). On the affordable side, we have No Nonsense Opaque Control Top tights ($6, Amazon).

I wanted to compare apples to apples as much as possible, so I made sure both pairs of tights were A) opaque, B) black, and C) had "control." Easy, right?

No.

ALL those words mean completely different things from brand to brand (and sometimes style to style). You can buy "opaque black tights" and end up with sheer grayish pantyhose, and I really think the lack of consistency puts people off. Tights brands, you can do better.

Even though words mean nothing in Pantyhose Kingdom, these two pairs seemed to be as similar to one another as possible. It was time to compare and contrast.

First: SIZING. Which brand is best when it comes to figuring out your size?

tights size guide
photo: Alle Connell / Revelist

Figuring out what size you wear in tights is a circle of hell. You might as well consult a troll that lives at the bottom of a well than half of the brand size guides online. Are you a small, medium, or queen? Are you a small (A), or small (B)? Are you a medium Queen, or a 2 (QT)?

Much of this complex algebra is not explained.

Tights sizing is supposed to be based on your height and weight, but there’s not much standardization between brands, so one generally has to spend a humiliating few minutes consulting charts and graphs on the back of the packet.

wolford tights size
photo: Alle / Revelist

This is the fancy Wolford size guide. Per the chart — which took me MUCH longer to figure out than I'd like to admit — Wolford’s size range goes from XS through XXL. Per that size guide, Wolford’s 2XL tights will fit people up to 6’3” who weight 200lbs+.

That's not exactly size inclusive — the 2XL is about the equivalent of a US size 16-18 — but it's not the worst range ever.

No Nonsense's size guide is... much less fancy.

tights size guide
photo: Alle / Revelist

Here is the No Nonsense size guide. Above, it couldn't be more simple! Online it is... more complicated. No Nonsense is definitely cheap, but if I wanted to figure out my size across styles, I'd end up with MULTIPLE different answers.

Anyway. No Nonsense’s sizing goes from S - XXL. Per the size chart, No Nonsense’s XXL tight in this style is for people up to 6” who weigh up to 300lbs. Again — not SUPER inclusive, but not a terrible start.

According to both Wolford and No Nonsense, I’m right on the cusp of sizes S and M.

photo: Giphy

I ordered size medium in both, based on years of Tall Person experience.

Next, I asked myself "Which brand has the best packaging?" Because when it comes to tights, that matters.

tights packaging
photo: Jess Torres / Revelist

Good packaging keeps the tights flat and stops creases and serious wrinkles from forming.

Bad packaging lets the tights get crushed up into an unattractive ball, which leaves you with lumpy-looking legs.

Wolford's tights looked luxurious the second you pick them up.

>> Click here to buy

The Wolford tights (Shopbop, $85) came in a BIG flat package, wrapped in heavy-duty plastic. This means the tights don't get too wrinkly as they're shipped.

The cheap No Nonsense tights had far more basic packaging.

>> Click here to buy

The No Nonsense tights ($6, Amazon) arrived just like this in a wrinkly plastic sack that immediately ripped open. The tights themselves were crumpled up pretty badly.

Even after laying flat for 48 hours, the difference cased by the packaging was clear. The crappy packaging left the No Nonsense tights (top) super-wrinkly and lumpy, while the Wolford tights (bottom) were smooth as a baby's butt.

best black tights
photo: Alle / Revelist

I finally understand all those people who tell you not to tie the legs of your tights in knots to store them! I get it now!

Because those wrinkles in the No Nonsense cheap tights? They did NOT come out.

And that wasn't the only problem.

Unwrapped and laid out, there was already a BIG size difference between the expensive tights (up top) and the cheap tights (below). And it did NOT make my tall person heart very happy to see.

best black tights
photo: Alle / Revelist

I immediately started sweating nervously, imaging trying to cram my legs into the doll-sized elastic tubes of the cheap tights. Visions of labial wedgies danced in my head.

Then it got worse.

The expensive Wolford tights felt smooth yet soft on the outside, and thick like good quality leggings.

The $6 tights felt like unexfoliated human skin — too slippery, yet somehow rough at the same time.

>> Click here to buy

If you, like me, have a Thing about textures, this is definitely something to consider. Why wear tights if they make you feel emotionally (and physically) crawly?

The expensive tights felt absolutely glorious on the inside — and even with my hand shoved down into the toes, they were SUPER opaque.

>> Click here to buy

This may seem silly, but I also really liked that the Wolford tights have a tag in the back (so you know which side IS the back) and built-in heels. Prevents a lot of confusion when you're getting dressed in the morning!

The cheap tights were slightly softer inside than outside, but were only reasonably opaque.

>> Click here to buy

The material the No Nonsense tights was made of was much thinner and felt more breathable than the expensive version, too.

I was starting to realize that I had no idea what I liked in tights — do I like thick material or thin? Do I like super-soft, or a little rougher? WHO KNOWS.

It was time to try both pairs of tights on. God help me.

Because the expensive tights had a built-in heel, putting them on was easier than anything I'd ever done before. These are 100% struggle-less tights.

>> Click here to buy

I'm used to jumping around, yanking the waistband towards my ears to get tights on. The Wolford tights ($85, Shopbop) were different — they were VERY snug, thanks to that "control" built in — they slid on easily, and I didn't need to do an interpretive dance to feel comfortable in them.

Once I pulled the $85 tights on, I was sold. I finally understood why people LIKE tights!

>> Click here to buy

These tights ($85, Shopbop) were soft, yet provided firm support. They were like getting a really good hug, but all over my lower body.

They were opaque — perhaps a little transparent around the contours of my ass, but honestly, what wouldn't become see-through in the presence of my butt?

Most importantly, the Wolford tights had a flat matte black finish that I really liked. Finally, I thought. I see why people actually wear these things!

The rise was high, without being cartoonish.

And they were just. So. Comfortable! I honestly couldn't believe it.

The Wolford tights were as black as my soul, and opaque enough to hide me from the eyes of God. They were also definitely warm enough for a New York winter.

>> Click here to buy

I felt secure that, if I bent over in these tights ($85, Shopbop), the entire world wouldn't see my crevices.

Additionally, after stretching sections of the tights to check the opacity, the Wolford tights snapped right back into shape which is extremely *chef's kiss*

The final test? I wore these tights with my most static-prone dress... and they didn't stick to my legs for even a second.

>> Click here to buy

What does Wolford *do* to these tights to make them so good? I'm guessing dark magic.

(And yes, the tights DID match the other black items in my wardrobe. Fellow goth queens know how important this is!)

After my expensive Wolford tights experience, I felt like this:

But would I feel similarly high-kicky after trying the $6 cheap tights?

There was only one way to find out.

I was not as immediately amazed by the No Nonsense $6 tights. As soon as I pulled them onto my feet, a run appeared by my ankle.

>> Click here to buy

That didn't bode well.

Then it got worse. Despite being thinner, the inexpensive tights were not very stretchy — and they were CLEARLY not made for tall people. I didn't even think I'd be able to get them on.

>> Click here to buy

Every tall person's nightmare — you put the tights on ($6, Amazon). You pull them up. And then... they stop. You have a sagging bridge between your knees. They won't go up over your butt without creative thinking.

I immediately started having flashbacks to my childhood.

Why.

Is.

This.

HAPPENING.

I finally got the cheap No Nonsense tights on, and readers, it was NOT GOOD.

>> Click here to buy

These tights are why I hate tights ($6, Amazon). They were uncomfortable to wear and even WORSE to think about — I suffered the physical indignity of tights cutting into my waist and strangling my thighs, while also knowing that my legs had been smooshed into weird shapes. The waistband came up almost to my armpits, but the crotch kept sliding down towards my knees.

I was not in to these, is what I'm saying.

Plus, on no planet are these opaque. These tights were semi-sheer, with a strange gold glitter shift across the control top section.

cheap tights review
photo: Jess Torres / Revelist

No Nonsense, or PLENTY of nonsense?

Seriously. You can see through these tights and into my soul.

These tights may look this sheer because I'm 5'10, and they're having to really WORK to cover my legs. But again — I ordered my size based on the arcane size guide provided by No Nonsense. They're meant to fit. Nobody should have to consult an oracle to get basic black tights that fit them!

As I tried to stop the crotch of these tights ($6) from sinking down to my knees (again), another run appeared — this time right by my knee.

And, as I slipped my dress over my head to test how clingy the inexpensive tights were, THE RUN GOT BIGGER.

This isn't as much a run in my tights as it is a wild sprint to my groin.

MIRACULOUSLY, the No Nonsense tights also didn't make my dress stick to them. And from a distance, they looked pretty cute! It was only up close that you realized...

The "black" tights looked to have a STRONG gray-brown tint. I had committed the cardinal sin of wearing non-matching black clothing!

I peeled the $6 tights off, truly annoyed at my life, at clothing, and at elastic in general.

So, what's the verdict? What did I, a noted tights-hater, take away from the experience?

For starters, I've seen the light. I am IN LOVE with the opaque Wolford tights ($85, Shopbop). I have never in my life worn a pair of tights that's so comfortable, and looks so damn good. I will gladly spend my money on these expensive-ass tights, and feel proud while I do so.

I learned that, in these two instances, you do get what you pay for. I didn't like the super-cheap cheap No Nonsense tights ($6, Amazon), but I *did* learn that a lot of the issues I had with stockings were because I was trying to cram my hams into cheap things. Tall girls, go Wolford. You won't regret it.

That said, I can really see the benefit in having cheap tights on hand. If you need "emergency tights," or you don't live in a place that gets cold very often, or if you're not on the taller end of things, I can imagine that the No Nonsense tights would definitely work. They'll probably get you from A to B, with only a few runs in the process.

But if you need to wear opaque black tights to an event, to work, or if you just enjoy NOT feeling like a butternut pumpkin stuffed into a condom, go Wolford. If they've made me a believer, just think about the brave new world of actually awesome tights waiting for you.