That time Reinhart tried to play it cool and claimed she wasn't starstruck by Sprouse when she first met him.
When W Magazine asked Reinhart about her first impression of Sprouse, Reinhart claimed she barely remembered their initial encounter.
"It's funny, I don’t really remember having an opinion on Cole, to be honest," Reinhart breezily remarked.
But fans saw right through Reinhart's dismissive response.
That time Reinhart got *very* protective over her private life.
In October, Reinhart went on a Tumblr rant about fans who are way too invested in her love life.
But rather than silence the gossip, fans started questioning what Reinhart was trying to hide.